CHAPTER / 06
Media: In the Middle of Things
Relating a medium’s form, financing and everyday use to the experience of its audience.
Chapter 06 · Media: In the Middle of Things
A family watches intimate conversations between television characters while having less time for its own: this contradiction becomes a sharp focus of Monaco’s account of the virtual family. Before reaching it, the chapter places film within a larger communications environment. Print, records, radio, television and video are not simply successive machines. They organize attention, routines and relationships. Separating a work’s visible form from the habits through which it is encountered would miss much of a medium’s social force. When a story changes medium, the surrounding arrangement of life may change as well as its presentation.
Monaco’s readings of Beckett’s work for different media offer a useful entry. The comparative questions concern audience choice in theatre, the relationship between camera and subject in film, vocal address and intimate imagery in television, and the organization of sound in radio. These are better treated as decisions demonstrated by particular works than as permanent essences of media. Other productions can use the same materials differently. An analytical comparison opens a medium’s possibilities; converting it into a law would close them again. Keep the example visible so that the proposed distinction can be tested rather than merely inherited.
The account of broadcasting business asks who pays and what that payment purchases. Advertising, network time, producers, reruns and audience measurement connect finance to the form and scheduling of programs. A public can be imagined as a community of citizens, a collection of customers or attention sold to advertisers; those conceptions imply different priorities. Counting the buttons on a remote control cannot establish the extent of viewer freedom. Ask what became available, which productions remained difficult to reach and whose measured activity influenced decisions. The business model is part of an account of address, not a detachable appendix to the supposedly real artistic work.
Map a familiar program’s sources of finance, routes of circulation and claims on a viewer’s day. Then compare the relationships on the screen with the setting in which the program is watched. Fictional companionship can relieve isolation while also competing with other uses of time. Monaco’s forceful judgements should prompt inquiry into different viewers and circumstances rather than become a uniform psychological diagnosis. The exercise asks a statement about media influence to account for form, social conditions and evidence of use together. It avoids treating an audience as an empty container into which a program deposits an identical effect, while preserving the seriousness of the chapter’s concern with everyday life. An account of use can combine viewers’ descriptions with observation of the viewing setting. A program’s form remains relevant evidence, but cannot by itself establish its consequences for a particular household.
Sections in the original chapter
- Community
- Print and Electronic Media
- The Technology of Mechanical and Electronic Media
- Radio and Records
- Television and Video
- “Broadcasting”: The Business
- “Television”: The Art
- “TV”: The Virtual Family
EYE/ERROR / VIEWING / THINKING
Take this to a film
- How does a program’s financing model imagine its audience?
- Where do onscreen relationships meet or differ from the setting in which the screen is watched?
BOOK / SOURCES / CREDITS
How to Read a Film: Movies, Media, and Beyond
James Monaco
Fourth edition, completely revised and expanded, 2009 · ISBN 978-0-19-532105-0
Oxford University Press · 2009
Media: In the Middle of Things
Chapter 06 · Media: In the Middle of Things
The explanations, critical applications and questions are EYE/ERROR’s original editorial work. Credit for the book belongs to its authors and publisher.
Full credits
- Original author: James Monaco
- Diagrams in the original book: David Lindroth
- Reading guides and exercises: EYE/ERROR editorial; not an authorized translation or reproduction
- The title and copyright pages identify the 2009 fourth edition; the publisher markets the same ISBN as the Thirtieth Anniversary Edition
