বাংলাFilms. Ideas. Perspectives.

IDEA / দৃষ্টি

GAZE

A woman’s presence before a camera does not establish whose look organises the scene.

Original sourcesলরা মালভি: ভিজুয়াল প্লেজার অ্যান্ড ন্যারেটিভ সিনেমা, স্ক্রিন, ১৯৭৫বেল হুকস: দ্য অপজিশনাল গেজ, ব্ল্যাক লুকস, ১৯৯২

A woman’s presence before a camera does not establish whose look organises the scene. Follow the cut: whose glance supplies information, whose reaction receives time, and whose body interrupts the action to become a spectacle? Laura Mulvey’s 1975 essay analyses relations between active looking and feminine display in classical Hollywood narrative. Its object is a system of cinematic pleasure and identification, rather than an assertion about the natural behaviour of every male viewer. A woman director or protagonist does not automatically transform that system.

bell hooks changes the map by attending to Black female spectators whose histories and identifications cannot be accommodated by an undifferentiated female spectator. Refusing identification with white femininity can itself become a critical activity. Her oppositional gaze is not another name for Mulvey’s argument: it also exposes exclusions in theories that fail to think race and gender together. Preserving that disagreement makes both texts more useful than a general slogan about men looking at women.

Try recording who receives a close-up after each glance, then listen for authority that comes from outside the frame. An unseen speaker may control a visible face; a withheld reaction may make identification difficult. Such observations give a political reading something specific to explain. A route from these essays to Persona is our proposed comparison, not evidence that Mulvey wrote the interpretation offered on this site. The task is to establish how a particular film distributes looking before assigning it a position.

Read the original sources

  1. লরা মালভি: ভিজুয়াল প্লেজার অ্যান্ড ন্যারেটিভ সিনেমা, স্ক্রিন, ১৯৭৫
  2. বেল হুকস: দ্য অপজিশনাল গেজ, ব্ল্যাক লুকস, ১৯৯২

One possible path

Mulvey → hooks → Persona