CHAPTER / 05
Film Theory: Form and Function
Reading theories through the relationship between what cinema is and what it does.
Chapter 05 · Film Theory: Form and Function
Two theorists can value the same film for different reasons: one emphasizes its relationship with a recorded world, another the constructive force of editing. Their disagreement concerns more than taste. It involves an account of where cinema’s powers reside. Monaco approaches the history of theory through form and function: what kind of thing cinema is, and how it acts on perception, knowledge or social experience. Keeping criticism beside theory makes a useful demand on an abstract claim. A concept should help explain a particular arrangement of images and sounds, rather than acquiring authority through a theorist’s name alone.
The discussions of Lindsay, Münsterberg, Arnheim, Kracauer and Soviet thinkers offer different descriptions of film’s artistic capacities. Read for the work done by their differences: how does a theory value the recorded world, and how does it understand the transformation of that material? Montage cannot be reduced to fast cutting, just as realism cannot be identified by location shooting alone. An argument must explain the organization within a shot, the relation between shots or the spectator’s contribution to an effect. A slogan placed under each writer’s name would preserve an impression of knowledge while losing the reasoning that makes the disagreement consequential.
The Bazin discussion foregrounds possibilities in the treatment of space and duration; Godard reopens relationships between images, language and politics. Metz supplies an analytical vocabulary for signification, while the chapter’s later account touches cognition, audiences and culture. This is a selected intellectual history rather than a complete map of film studies. Its distribution of attention should itself be examined. Monaco’s reservations about the value of later theoretical developments express an authorial position; they do not establish that a field has finished thinking. The guide therefore follows his route without treating its boundaries as the boundaries of worthwhile inquiry.
Test one scene through two questions: how does the relation between its images generate an idea, and how much freedom does its arrangement give a spectator to select attention? The same evidence can acquire different weight in the two readings. Describe what each explains and what remains outside it. This editorial comparison need not declare a winning theorist. Theory becomes useful when it puts pressure on an apparently natural preference, making the critic specify what a convention does, whose experience it organizes and which assumptions are necessary for its force. The return to the scene prevents a history of concepts from becoming a substitute for looking. When citing a theoretical phrase, return to its example and publication context. A familiar later slogan can conceal the original problem; distinguishing that history from your application keeps the comparison intellectually accountable.
Sections in the original chapter
- The Critic
- The Poet and the Philosopher: Lindsay and Münsterberg
- Expressionism and Realism: Arnheim and Kracauer
- Montage: Pudovkin, Eisenstein, Balázs, and Formalism
- Mise-en-Scène: Neorealism, Bazin, and Godard
- Film Speaks and Acts: Metz and Contemporary Theory
EYE/ERROR / VIEWING / THINKING
Take this to a film
- Which evidence changes importance when two theories address the same scene?
- Which question receives too little space in Monaco’s map and deserves further reading?
BOOK / SOURCES / CREDITS
How to Read a Film: Movies, Media, and Beyond
James Monaco
Fourth edition, completely revised and expanded, 2009 · ISBN 978-0-19-532105-0
Oxford University Press · 2009
Film Theory: Form and Function
Chapter 05 · Film Theory: Form and Function
The explanations, critical applications and questions are EYE/ERROR’s original editorial work. Credit for the book belongs to its authors and publisher.
Full credits
- Original author: James Monaco
- Diagrams in the original book: David Lindroth
- Reading guides and exercises: EYE/ERROR editorial; not an authorized translation or reproduction
- The title and copyright pages identify the 2009 fourth edition; the publisher markets the same ISBN as the Thirtieth Anniversary Edition
