বাংলাFilms. Ideas. Perspectives.
How to Read a Film: Movies, Media, and Beyond

CHAPTER / 01

Film as an Art

How cinema reorganizes materials shared with other arts rather than merely adding them together.

BOOK: James Monaco · 2009GUIDE: EYE/ERROR EDITORIAL

Chapter 01 · Film as an Art

A room described in a novel, encountered onstage and entered through a film does not become the same experience simply because its furniture is recognizable. Monaco begins by placing cinema among other arts: painting, photography, literature, music, theatre and architecture. The comparison need not establish cinema as a victorious synthesis that supersedes its predecessors. Its more useful task is to ask how each medium distributes attention, organizes duration and makes the presence of a teller perceptible. Those differences let a critic describe a particular film’s decisions rather than awarding it an abstract place in a hierarchy.

Monaco offers several maps of artistic experience, including degrees of abstraction, modes of discourse and relations of production. The artist, the work and the observer form a changing relationship rather than three isolated entities. Production and consumption bring economic, technical, psychological and political pressures into that relationship. The same moving image can be screened in an exhibition, sold in a cinema or watched in a living room, while the social arrangement of attention changes. His diagrams work best as instruments of comparison. Treating them as permanent compartments would remove the interactions that make the maps productive in the first place.

The comparison with the novel makes narration especially important. A verbal description can carry a teller’s judgement; a film can distribute information through performance, setting, sound and the frame. This does not make the visible image neutral, nor does it mean that cinema lacks narration. Distance, framing, staging and editing organize what becomes available to the viewer. An image contains contingent detail, but it is also the product of decisions and labor. Read Monaco’s contrasts as prompts for examining those decisions, without converting literature into pure abstraction or cinema into an unmediated piece of reality. Neither medium simply delivers a world intact.

Try the chapter against a scene of someone arriving in an empty room. Describe how speech, prose narration, an uninterrupted stage arrangement and a moving camera would establish the absence differently. List what each arrangement withholds as carefully as what it supplies. A pause that carries the strain of a live performance might acquire another force through a cut, an offscreen sound or an apparently insignificant object. This is an editorial exercise rather than a recipe attributed to Monaco. It turns a comparison between arts into accountable criticism: what, precisely, does the chosen organization make the spectator notice, imagine or wait for? Specify the observer imagined in the comparison, too. Differences between a reader, a theatre audience and a screen spectator can involve a situation of attention as well as an artistic medium.

Sections in the original chapter
  • The Nature of Art
  • Ways of Looking at Art
  • The Spectrum of Abstraction
  • The Modes of Discourse
  • The “Rapports de Production”
  • Film, Recording, and the Other Arts
  • Film, Photography, and Painting
  • Film and the Novel
  • Film and Theater
  • Film and Music
  • Film and the Environmental Arts
  • The Structure of Art

EYE/ERROR / VIEWING / THINKING

Take this to a film

  1. Which sources of information change when a scene moves between prose and cinema?
  2. How do artistic form and the arrangement of exhibition each organize attention?
Your reading progress stays in this browser.

BOOK / SOURCES / CREDITS

How to Read a Film: Movies, Media, and Beyond

James Monaco

Fourth edition, completely revised and expanded, 2009 · ISBN 978-0-19-532105-0
Oxford University Press · 2009

Film as an Art
Chapter 01 · Film as an Art

The explanations, critical applications and questions are EYE/ERROR’s original editorial work. Credit for the book belongs to its authors and publisher.

Full credits
  • Original author: James Monaco
  • Diagrams in the original book: David Lindroth
  • Reading guides and exercises: EYE/ERROR editorial; not an authorized translation or reproduction
  • The title and copyright pages identify the 2009 fourth edition; the publisher markets the same ISBN as the Thirtieth Anniversary Edition