CHAPTER / 08 / Film as Text
Mainstream and Alternative Film Form
Compare forms through causality, information and relations of identification.
Printed p. 132 · supplied 2001 first edition
What happened and when viewers learn it are different questions. This chapter explains mainstream narration through causal relationships, character goals and the organization of time and space. Reconstructing events after a film ends differs from receiving information during a first viewing. An unexpected interruption and anticipation of a known danger can produce different experiences. This distinction moves formal analysis beyond retelling a story toward describing how narration makes that story available.
The chapter also considers restrictions of knowledge and different forms of subjectivity. An optical point-of-view shot is not identical to access to a character's mental experience. Sound and editing can place us within someone's uncertainty without presenting a literal view through their eyes. A film may change its distribution of knowledge from scene to scene. Attaching one fixed narrational label to the entire work can therefore conceal the local decisions that make a sequence effective.
Alternative narration and counter-cinema bring conventional pleasure and identification into question. Interruption, repetition or acknowledgment of construction can ask spectators to undertake different work. Yet a linear plot does not automatically imply intellectual passivity, and fragmentation does not guarantee political liberation. A useful application identifies which convention is challenged, who is being addressed and what relationship replaces the familiar one. Naming a departure is the beginning of an argument about form, not its conclusion.
For our original exercise, write two lists for a sequence: the chronological order of events and the order in which information reaches the viewer. Mark where spectators know more, less or approximately as much as a character. Consider how moving one disclosure would alter feeling or judgment. The same method can investigate alternative forms: when closure is withheld, where does the film relocate the viewer's work? Attention to these particulars makes comparison more exact than a simple opposition between obedient mainstream cinema and supposedly emancipatory experimentation.
EYE/ERROR / VIEWING / THINKING
Take this to a film
- Where do the order of events and the order of disclosure diverge?
- What new work does a formal disruption ask viewers to perform?
BOOK / SOURCES / CREDITS
Studying Film
Nathan Abrams, Ian Bell and Jan Udris
First edition, 2001 · ISBN 0-340-76134-2
Arnold, London; co-published in the United States by Oxford University Press · 2001
Mainstream and Alternative Film Form
Printed p. 132 · supplied 2001 first edition
The explanations, critical applications and questions are EYE/ERROR’s original editorial work. Credit for the book belongs to its authors and publisher.
Full credits
- Original book and chapter authors: Nathan Abrams, Ian Bell and Jan Udris
- Studying the Media series editor: Tim O’Sullivan
- Reading guides and exercises: EYE/ERROR editorial; not an authorized translation or reproduction
- The linked Bloomsbury listing is the later second edition, not the supplied 2001 text
