CHAPTER / 10 / Critical Approaches to Film
Genre
Connect repetition and difference with industry, audiences and historical change.
Printed p. 174 · supplied 2001 first edition
Viewers can often anticipate a kind of danger, romance or resolution before a film explains very much. Recognizable generic cues make that anticipation possible. This chapter approaches genre through recurring settings, objects, sounds, characters and narrative relationships. Repetition alone, however, would offer little reason to encounter another film. Difference supplies renewal. Genre works through the tension between a promise of familiarity and the possibility that the familiar arrangement will be redirected or put under pressure.
Genre is not only a critic's classification. Producers and distributors use it to organize work and marketing, while audiences can use it to manage the uncertainty of choosing a film. Publicity's category may not match what particular scenes accomplish. A film can combine several traditions, and the same label can carry different expectations at different times. Comparing a campaign's promise with the film's actual deployment of conventions therefore gives the concept a practical critical use.
The chapter also links genres with society and history. Recurring conflicts or resolutions can become ways of discussing a culture's assumptions. Yet a film is not an exact photograph of an entire society's collective mind. Specify which viewers, historical conditions and competing interpretations make the proposed meaning plausible. Broad categories organized around confrontation or emotional agreement can assist comparison, but awkward examples should expose a category's limits rather than be forced into it.
For our original application, compare two films associated with one genre and record both a repeated cue and the work it performs. A doorway, song or pursuit might reassure in one context and threaten in another. Then compare the identity stressed in publicity with the values endorsed or unsettled by each ending. The aim is not simply to improve recognition of genre names. It is to show how a film activates, revises or troubles the audience's existing knowledge of a recognizable cinematic tradition.
EYE/ERROR / VIEWING / THINKING
Take this to a film
- What different work does the same cue perform in two films?
- Where does the film revise the generic promise of its publicity?
BOOK / SOURCES / CREDITS
Studying Film
Nathan Abrams, Ian Bell and Jan Udris
First edition, 2001 · ISBN 0-340-76134-2
Arnold, London; co-published in the United States by Oxford University Press · 2001
Genre
Printed p. 174 · supplied 2001 first edition
The explanations, critical applications and questions are EYE/ERROR’s original editorial work. Credit for the book belongs to its authors and publisher.
Full credits
- Original book and chapter authors: Nathan Abrams, Ian Bell and Jan Udris
- Studying the Media series editor: Tim O’Sullivan
- Reading guides and exercises: EYE/ERROR editorial; not an authorized translation or reproduction
- The linked Bloomsbury listing is the later second edition, not the supplied 2001 text
