Film Critic / Editor
SERGE DANEY
Serge Daney was a French film critic associated with Cahiers du cinéma, Libération and the journal Trafic. His writing connects particular images to the education of a spectator and to the changing conditions under which cinema and other images circulate. The Tracking Shot in Kapò, published in Trafic in 1992, is an autobiographical critical essay, rather than a direct review based on his having watched Kapò.
Daney explicitly acknowledges that Rivette’s account of the shot reached him before the film itself. EYE/ERROR preserves that distinction because it changes what kind of evidence the essay offers. Our exercise asks critics to identify the images they have seen, the descriptions they have inherited and the relations a formal decision establishes. Ethical attention requires that precision, including honesty about the limits of one’s own viewing.
Read the original sources
CORE IDEAS
Image ethics
Distance
Cinephilia
Spectatorship
START HERE
CRITIC’S METHODWHERE DOES THE CAMERA STAND?
An ethical judgment about an image has to account for how the image was made available to us. In The Tracking Shot in Kapò, Serge Daney recalls the force of Jacques Rivette’s 1961 condemnation of a camera movement in Gillo Pontecorvo’s film. Daney is explicit that he had not seen Kapò: the shot reached him through Rivette’s words. That fact is essential to the essay. It concerns the transmission of a critical conviction and the formation of a spectator, as well as the relation between a camera movement and the suffering it depicts.
