বাংলাFilms. Ideas. Perspectives.
08

CRITIC’S METHOD

WHERE DOES THE CAMERA STAND?

SERGE DANEY

Original sourcesSerge Daney, The Tracking Shot in Kapò (1992): English translation, Senses of Cinema

An ethical judgment about an image has to account for how the image was made available to us. In The Tracking Shot in Kapò, Serge Daney recalls the force of Jacques Rivette’s 1961 condemnation of a camera movement in Gillo Pontecorvo’s film. Daney is explicit that he had not seen Kapò: the shot reached him through Rivette’s words. That fact is essential to the essay. It concerns the transmission of a critical conviction and the formation of a spectator, as well as the relation between a camera movement and the suffering it depicts.

Our exercise begins by separating three things: the event represented, the formal decision made about it and the spectator’s access to that decision. A film about atrocity does not acquire ethical authority from its subject alone. Ask what a reframing, cut, musical cue or held look makes available as pleasure, knowledge or spectacle. The issue is more exact than whether an image is beautiful. A particular arrangement can turn a person’s suffering into an opportunity for the film to display its own effect. That claim needs a description of the arrangement and the relation it establishes.

Daney’s essay also requires honesty about mediation. Have we seen the film, seen an excerpt, read a description or inherited a verdict? Each offers a different basis for a claim. A striking account can educate perception, but it can also become a formula repeated without renewed examination. When using a clip, identify what the excerpt leaves outside it. When relying on criticism, distinguish the earlier critic’s observation from your own. This is EYE/ERROR’s methodological extension of the essay’s remarkable admission. It applies to everyday online viewing as much as to arguments about the history of cinema.

For a filmmaker, the question is where your intervention places you in relation to the people filmed. What permission does an image presume, what distance does it maintain, and whose vulnerability supplies its force? For a critic, avoid turning ethical attention into a list of forbidden camera movements. The same device can establish very different relationships in different circumstances. Describe the specific act and its conditions before judging it. Daney’s essay remains challenging because it links a seemingly local formal choice to the wider education of a gaze, including the words and institutions through which we learn to see.

Read the original sources

  1. Serge Daney, The Tracking Shot in Kapò (1992): English translation, Senses of Cinema