Film Critic
PAULINE KAEL
Pauline Kael was an American film critic whose long association with The New Yorker made her prose central to public arguments about movies. Her criticism ranges across performance, popular pleasure, genre, cultural prestige and the experience of an audience. The collected selection The Age of Movies includes Trash, Art, and the Movies, a key text in her challenge to received distinctions of taste.
Her place in this reading room begins with the connection between response and description. A forceful personal voice is useful when it can show readers what produced its enthusiasm or resistance. EYE/ERROR’s exercise follows a reaction back into the film’s acting, movement and rhythm. It is a practical extension of reading Kael, with room to dispute her individual judgments rather than treating her reputation as a substitute for an argument.
Read the original sources
CORE IDEAS
Response
Evidence
Performance
Popular cinema
START HERE
CRITIC’S METHODRESPONSE / EVIDENCE
A response arrives before an argument is finished. A performance irritates us; an extravagant scene delights us; a supposedly important film leaves us cold. Pauline Kael’s criticism makes such reactions available for scrutiny without requiring them to become respectable in advance. Her 1969 essay Trash, Art, and the Movies is a productive starting point for examining the relation between cultural prestige and movie pleasure. The essay supplies a question about value, rather than a rule that whatever entertains must be good. Our method asks a reader to investigate the experience that a judgment names.
FILM × CRITICTHE GODFATHER
Where does power’s beauty place the spectator?
