বাংলাFilms. Ideas. Perspectives.
03

CRITIC’S METHOD

RESPONSE / EVIDENCE

PAULINE KAEL

Original sourcesPauline Kael, Trash, Art, and the Movies, Harper’s, February 1969: original publication recordLibrary of America: The Age of Movies and Kael’s critical practice

A response arrives before an argument is finished. A performance irritates us; an extravagant scene delights us; a supposedly important film leaves us cold. Pauline Kael’s criticism makes such reactions available for scrutiny without requiring them to become respectable in advance. Her 1969 essay Trash, Art, and the Movies is a productive starting point for examining the relation between cultural prestige and movie pleasure. The essay supplies a question about value, rather than a rule that whatever entertains must be good. Our method asks a reader to investigate the experience that a judgment names.

Begin by making an honest note of a reaction, then identify its trigger as precisely as possible. A laugh may depend on the interval before a reply, an actor’s physical awkwardness, a familiar convention or an audience’s recognition. The initial feeling does not settle which explanation is convincing. Return to the scene and compare them. In this EYE/ERROR exercise, enthusiasm earns its authority through the detail it can illuminate. Dislike faces the same demand. Declaring a film empty gives a reader little to examine until we describe how its gestures, rhythms or dramatic promises produced that impression.

The critic also has to account for the prestige surrounding a film. A serious subject can protect conventional filmmaking from close attention; a disreputable genre can conceal inventive performance or a lively relation to its audience. These are hypotheses to test scene by scene, rather than verdicts to apply in advance. Ask what your response owes to publicity, reputation, taste and previous viewing. A change of mind can be a discovery when the new claim explains evidence that the old one neglected. Consistency of method matters more than manufacturing a stable personality of praise and contempt.

For a filmmaker, this approach encourages attention to the exact pleasures a scene offers and the expectations it sets in motion. What happens between an intended effect and a viewer’s actual response? For an audience, it makes disagreement more useful: two people can compare what each heard and saw instead of exchanging final scores. Kael is a starting point for this exercise, not an authority who supplies our conclusion. A forceful critical voice becomes valuable when its confidence invites readers to inspect the film and to challenge the account with a more persuasive description.

Read the original sources

  1. Pauline Kael, Trash, Art, and the Movies, Harper’s, February 1969: original publication record
  2. Library of America: The Age of Movies and Kael’s critical practice