ORIGINAL CRITICISM / 10
Au hasard Balthazar
Au hasard Balthazar
The Criterion Collection / Current · 13 June 2005Read the original essay

James Quandt examines the density produced by Bresson’s austerity. He tests the temptation to treat the donkey’s life as a straightforward Christian allegory. Religious associations remain present, but matching each incident to a sacred equivalent conceals material relations and moral ambiguity.
Money, documents, restraints, and working hands become central evidence. Animal and human captivity run alongside each other without becoming identical experiences. Quandt connects sound, fragmented bodies, and clipped editing to a world of control. Feeling compassion does not establish that spiritual redemption has occurred.
EYE/ERROR / AFTER READING
Return to the film
- Which sound suggests a power outside the frame?
- What material exchange complicates a religious interpretation of the scene?
CREDIT AND SOURCE
Au hasard Balthazar
James Quandt · The Criterion Collection / Current · 13 June 2005
Rights in the original criticism belong to its author and rights holders. The original essay is not reproduced on this page.
The Criterion Collection / Current / ORIGINAL ESSAY