CHAPTER / 1
Errol Morris: American iconoclast
An image’s persuasiveness and a claim’s truth are different problems.
Printed p. 1
A fluent witness is not necessarily a truthful witness. Baker’s account of Errol Morris begins with this difficulty and with his resistance to the idea that one documentary style guarantees authenticity. Fixed framing, constructed lighting and direct address disturb conventions associated with unobtrusive observation. Their significance is not that they become a superior certificate of truth. Morris challenges the certificate itself: adopting a visual procedure cannot settle the status of what somebody says.
The reconstructions in The Thin Blue Line are therefore crucial. Baker describes repeated versions of the crime that follow conflicting testimony. These are not simply missing actuality supplied by actors. Their changing viewpoints make the instability of the accounts available to perception. A reconstruction can expose the structure of a false claim, but its polished appearance can also encourage an audience to mistake an assertion for an established event. That tension requires close attention to the relation between testimony and image.
In Baker’s discussions of Mr. Death and The Fog of War, self-explanation also becomes an object of scrutiny. Allowing somebody to speak does not automatically endorse them, yet extended speech does not automatically become critical either. Archive, music, graphics and juxtaposition work upon the interview, testing the distance between a person’s account of their motives and the consequences being examined. The critical task is to describe that work precisely rather than to infer a responsible film from its maker’s intentions.
Our proposed exercise is to label each element of a reconstruction by evidentiary status: documented action, witness recollection, inference, or disputed claim. Then ask which lighting, framing or continuity decision gives uncertainty the appearance of settled fact. This is an editorial application of the chapter, not a method prescribed verbatim by Morris. Its purpose is to keep an attractive invitation to doubt connected to the harder obligation of explaining why a particular claim survives investigation.
EYE/ERROR / VIEWING / THINKING
Take this to a film
- Whose account does a reconstruction visualize, and how is that status signalled?
- Where does archive material argue with the interview?
BOOK / SOURCES / CREDITS
Documentary in the Digital Age
Maxine Baker
First edition, 2006 · ISBN 978-0-240-51688-2
Focal Press, an imprint of Elsevier · 2006
Errol Morris: American iconoclast
Printed p. 1
The explanations, critical applications and questions are EYE/ERROR’s original editorial work. Credit for the book belongs to its authors and publisher.
Full credits
- Original book: Maxine Baker, copyright 2006
- Festival and funding appendix research and compilation: Mark Boulos, acknowledged by Baker
- Original reading guides and questions: EYE/ERROR editorial; not an authorized translation or reproduction
