The Specificity Thesis
Philosophical Problems of Classical Film Theory
READING / THE ARGUMENT
HOW THE IDEA WORKS
Carroll challenges strict medium specificity: the legitimate work of an art form cannot be logically deduced from one defining property.
Carroll introduces an is/ought distinction. No prescription about subject or technique follows logically from describing film's photographic or moving properties; a medium opens multiple legitimate possibilities.
CRITICAL LIMIT
A DISTINCTION TO KEEP IN VIEW
Rejecting prescriptive specificity does not make medium analysis irrelevant; it requires an explicit argument connecting description to evaluation.
This is EYE/ERROR’s editorial analysis, not a quotation or translation of the original.
SOURCES / RETURN TO THE PUBLICATION
Noël Carroll
“The Specificity Thesis”
- ANTHOLOGY
- Film Theory and Criticism: Introductory Readings, Seventh Edition, edited by Leo Braudy / Marshall Cohen, Oxford University Press, 2009. ISBN 978-0-19-536562-7.
- PUBLICATION TRAIL
- Philosophical Problems of Classical Film Theory
This guide is not a substitute for the original. The anthology contents and permissions credits support author, title, and publication metadata. A publisher record is not a full text; available original texts are identified in the links. A bibliographic record does not establish that every claim in the full work has been independently verified.
PREVIOUS / NEXT
